Taylor has been honored for its work by leading organizations in public relations and consumer marketing. Some of the awards bestowed upon the agency in recent years include:
- Consumer Agency of the Decade
- 2009 Strategic Agency of the Year
- 2008 U.S. Agency of the Year
- 2007 & 2008 Midsize Agency of the Year
- 2009 Cannes Lion Award: Best Public Relations Led Integrated Campaign (Guinness)
- 2012 PRSA Silver Anvil: Marketing Consumer Products/Alcoholic Beverages (Diageo/Sterling Vineyards)
- 2012 PRSA Chicago Skyline Awards: Multicultural (Allstate) and Creative Tactics (Allstate)
- 2012 PRSA Bronze Anvil: B-Roll (Diageo / Captain Morgan)
- 2012 PRSA Bronze Anvil: Media Relations-Consumer Services (Allstate)
- 2010 PRSA Silver Anvil: Reputation \ Brand Management (IAC \ Ask.com)
- 2009 PRSA Silver Anvil: Marketing Consumer Products-Packaged Goods (Kleenex)
- 2009 PRSA Silver Anvil: Marketing Consumer Products-Alcoholic Beverages (Guinness)
- 2008 PRSA Silver Anvil: Marketing Consumer Products (Staples)
- 2011 SABRE Award: Sponsorship (P&G)
- 2011 Global SABRE Award: Sponsorship (P&G)
- 2010 SABRE Award: Beer, Wine and Spirits (Guinness)
- 2009 SABRE Award: Household Products (Kleenex)
- 2008 Midsize Agency of the Year: PR News
- 2008 Mercury Awards for Excellence: Platinum Achievement Award
- 2012 American In-House Design Award
- Gold: 2013 Hermes Creative Awards