The Unstoppable Cultural Impact of TikTok: Ban or No Ban

Gather round the cauldron of the internet, where platform soup is boiling over, and social media’s most darling channel is on the precipice of getting tossed out of the pot. Headlines are spinning as the fate and future of TikTok seems to change by the minute, its ban would mark the end of an era for the app that captivated more than 170 million U.S. users and 7 million businesses. Since its infancy in 2016, TikTok grew to ultimately revolutionize short-form storytelling, supercharge the creator economy, rewire music discovery, and push brands to engage people in more innovative ways.

The political circus and drama around TikTok and other major platforms underscores the fragility of even the most dominant digital spaces when caught in the crosshairs of regulatory scrutiny. While the lawyers of TikTok opine, creators post heartfelt goodbyes, and users clock record hours of farewell screentime — here’s a few things we’re reflecting on.

TikTok’s Legacy as a Cultural Force

Like platform predecessors of the past (we’re looking at you Vine) and with a helping hand from a global pandemic, TikTok shifted how and by whom we are entertained. It launched short-form video into a different stratosphere unencumbered by the aesthetic tendencies and performative posting practices of other platforms. Trends quickly boiled over outside the app influencing culture at large. Content thrived on repetition and iteration, carrying an invitation to co-create and participate in a way that made people part of the moment vs mere viewers. Democratization of content creation uplifted new voices, and viral moments launched personal brands and new careers in a matter of days. Curiosity and discovery thrived, with an algorithm that at times seemed to know you better than your therapist. Not only catering to existing interests, but introducing things you never knew you wanted to know. An endless scroll to transport your brain through rabbit holes to learn to make sourdough, install a wig, optimize your resume, understand neurodivergence, dance, sing, get more protein, learn a new language, find a new blush, or just watch an entire movie in 10 minute clips. 

At the same time, TikTok’s addictive nature raised concerns about attention spans, mental health, and productivity. Yet, its unfiltered, chaotic, and absurdly funny culture—especially visible in its comment sections—set it apart as a space where authenticity reigned supreme. Unlike platforms like Instagram and Facebook, TikTok was perceived as less censored, allowing users to explore topics freely and openly. This openness cultivated a global community where Americans, often seen as the “class clowns of the internet,” drive much of the platform’s entertainment value. Despite stereotypes about international disdain for American culture, the looming ban has shown the opposite: creators worldwide are expressing how much they’ll miss the unique energy, humor, and cultural influence Americans bring to the app. 

TikTok’s responsiveness to trends and events has made it an essential cultural touchpoint for users everywhere to quickly gain a better understanding of human behavior and belief systems of specific communities. As Americans mourn the potential loss of TikTok, their influence is already migrating to other platforms like Xiaohongshu (RedNote), where international followers are eager to keep pace with the people and culture that have defined their experience of the platform.

Digital Communities and the Evolution of the Creator Economy

As any parent will attest, restricting screen time or taking away a favorite toy will unleash a level of petulance and outrage that will test even the most steadfast of patience and good intentions. Anti-Meta sentiment heightened significantly after people discovered how much Meta contributed to lobbying the ban, ultimately turning more TikTok first/only creators and users off to the idea of investing more time and energy in Reels. As users contemplate where they will go and what they will scroll next (IG Reels, YouTube Shorts, RedNote, Lemon8), they’re ultimately seeking the next iteration of digital community and creative expression that makes TikTok feel larger than a phone screen. 

For creators themselves, and the multi billion dollar creator economy, the stakes are higher. For many, TikTok wasn’t just entertainment; it was a livelihood. Its loss comes at a time of economic uncertainty, compounding challenges for people already navigating a precarious job market. While seasoned creators may pivot to other platforms or diversify income streams through creator owned monetization platforms like Patreon and Substack, many will struggle to recover lost opportunities. Industries that came to rely on TikTok’s community-driven economy will also feel the impact. For example, #BookTok revitalized physical and online bookstores, driving significant sales through viral recommendations. Without TikTok, brands, creators, and consumers face the challenge of rebuilding fragmented ecosystems on less engaging platforms.

Unsurprisingly (see above petulance), initial backlash toward adopting other legacy social platforms Meta, YouTube, Twitter/X, etc is shining a light on what's lacking in existing community, content, and algorithm experiences. TikTok stands out for its exceptionally high user engagement, where a small but active group of creators drives content consumption for a massive audience. Whether through emerging platforms or enhancements to existing spaces, the next wave of digital community will need to build upon TikTok’s sense of immediacy, creativity, and connection to succeed.

Implications for Brands: Pivoting With or Without TikTok

For brands, a potential TikTok shutdown serves as a call to reassess strategies and diversify partnerships. Successful collaborations must extend beyond audience size on a single platform to encompass broader creator ecosystems, such as podcasts, merchandise, newsletters, or live events. TikTok Shop has become a formidable online marketplace, especially for health and beauty, which may leave some brands with a revenue gap and others searching for new ways to create viral demand. Lastly, for brands maintaining or considering owned channels this is a good moment to examine what worked in the past. What made a campaign disruptive, and how can that energy be adapted for new environments? It also presents a moment for reinvention. In an era of efficiency where fewer assets are programmatically distributed to more places, emerging platforms and alternative approaches can offer brands a chance to discover new flavors of a brand’s identity and engage audiences in novel ways.

Final Thoughts

Expecting the social media landscape to remain static is a recipe for irrelevance. Platforms rise and fall, user behaviors change, and the people controlling money and influence inevitably shift. TikTok didn’t just create trends; it allowed users to co-create and participate in them, fostering a sense of inclusion and collective creativity. TikTok may feel irreplaceable today, but it wasn’t even part of most channel strategies just a few years ago. The key to thriving in this ever-changing landscape lies in adaptability: trying, failing, learning, and trying again.

People and professionals crave predictions and absolutes. As unsettling as it feels to face more questions than answers, this moment demands collective curiosity and a willingness to explore new frontiers. In the end, it’s about crafting a new recipe for success—one that embraces change and seizes the opportunities it brings.

Show full transcript
Hide transcript

Get the full report

Thank you! You can now download the document.
Download PDF
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Download PDFDownload PDF
PDF Viewer